Algebraic geometry
K-stability and GIT for cubic hypersurfaces
Abstract
In this note, we exhibit the proof that K-(semi/poly)stability of cubic hypersurfaces of dimension at least five coincide with the corresponding GIT stability. In particular, their K-moduli and GIT moduli stacks are isomorphic. The main step is to show that every K-semistable ℚ-Gorenstein limit of smooth cubic hypersurfaces is again a cubic hypersurface. We establish Cartierness of the limiting hyperplane divisor using local log canonical thresholds and mixed intersections. When its linear system has full-dimensional image, the codimension of the base locus strengthens the threshold estimate enough to apply the normalized-volume bound for local complete intersections. In the remaining case, tangent-sheaf semistability and adjunction theory reduce the image to a Segre cone and the geometry of its general fiber then gives the required Cartierness.
1. Introduction
1.1. Background and main result.
K-stability, introduced by Tian [Tia97] and reformulated algebraically by Donaldson [Don02], relates the existence of Kähler–Einstein metrics to the geometry of degenerations of Fano varieties. The algebraic theory now provides moduli stacks of K-semistable Fano varieties with projective good moduli spaces parametrizing K-polystable varieties; see [ABHLX20, BLX22, BX19, XZ20, Jia20, LWX21, LXZ22] and the references therein. Describing these moduli spaces explicitly, however, requires control of the varieties that occur on their boundary.
For several families, the moduli continuity method identifies the K-moduli compactification with a classical GIT quotient. Examples include del Pezzo surfaces [OSS16], intersections of two quadrics [SS17], cubic threefolds [LX19], and cubic fourfolds [Liu22]. A central ingredient is the comparison between the anticanonical volume of a K-semistable Fano variety and the normalized volumes of its singularities. The latter invariant was introduced by C. Li [Li18]. For varieties of large anticanonical volume, this comparison places strong restrictions on possible degenerations.
In this paper we study cubic hypersurfaces in higher dimensions. If is a smooth cubic -fold and , then
Liu–Xu [LX19, Theorem 1.1] and Liu [Liu22, Theorem 1.1] proved that K-stability and GIT stability agree in dimensions three and four, respectively. Kong–Shen–Zhao–Zhao [KSZZ26a] established the corresponding result for cubic fivefolds. We prove the following statement uniformly for all .
Let denote the K-moduli stack parametrizing K-semistable Fano -folds of anticanon-ical volume that admit a -Gorenstein smoothing to a smooth cubic. Let be the GIT-semistable locus in the projective space of cubic forms on , and set
We test GIT stability using and use the effective projective action for the quotient stack.
Theorem 1.1. Let , and let be a cubic hypersurface. Then is K-semistable (respectively, K-polystable or K-stable) if and only if the cubic form is GIT-semistable (respectively, GIT-polystable or GIT-stable) for the natural action of . Moreover, there is a natural isomorphism .
Remark 1.2. The implication from K-stability to GIT stability is standard for Fano hypersurfaces as the CM polarization is a positive rational multiple of the usual GIT polarization; see [PT06] and the discussion following [Liu22, Theorem 1.1]. The content of Theorem 1.1 is the converse and the identification of the compactifications. In particular, every smooth cubic -fold is K-stable, since smooth cubics are GIT-stable.
1.2. Outline of the proof.
The main difficulty is to show that the K-moduli boundary still parametrizes cubic hypersurfaces. Let be a K-semistable -Gorenstein limit of smooth cubic -folds. By [Liu22, Theorem 3.1], the limiting hyperplane class is an ample integral -Cartier Weil divisor satisfying
and is Cartier. The classification of del Pezzo varieties then reduces the problem to proving that itself is Cartier. Our main geometric result is the following.
Theorem 1.3. Let be a K-semistable -Gorenstein limit of smooth cubic -folds, where . Then its limiting hyperplane divisor is Cartier, and embeds as a cubic hypersurface in .
Proof. Let be the divisor supplied by Theorem 3.1. Then , , , and is Cartier. Put . Then we have by Corollary 6.13 and the cartierness of follows from Proposition 5.5. The embedding follows from [Fuj90, Corollary 1.7].
Proof of Theorem 1.1. This follows from the moduli continuity argument of [LX19, proof of Theorem 1.1] and also [Liu22, proof of Theorem 1.1].
The local obstruction is particularly useful. At a non-Cartier point, the index cover associated to is a nonsmooth Gorenstein klt germ whose normalized volume is strictly greater than . It therefore cannot be a local complete intersection, by [Liu22, Theorem 1.3]. On the other hand, we show that a Gorenstein klt germ of dimension with a proper ideal of log canonical threshold greater than is a hypersurface germ (Lemma 4.5). The proof cuts down to a Gorenstein klt surface and uses the classification of Du Val singularities. Thus a sufficiently strong threshold bound for the lifted sections of forces Cartierness.
Write for the geometric base locus of . To obtain the threshold bound, set
On the normalized graph , write , where and are the free and fixed parts of the pulled-back degree-one system, and put . The mixed-intersection estimate gives the following lower bound for the threshold of the degree-one base ideal on each index 1 cover:
The useful additional observation is that if has codimension , then , while the local threshold bound gives . These two statements can be used successively to improve both the codimension and the threshold.
Suppose first that . Nondegeneracy gives . Together with the preceding equalities, this first forces and then gives . The local criterion now applies at every non-Cartier point, proving Cartierness of in this case. This is the argument of Section 5.
When , the mixed intersections vanish for , so a different input is needed. Semistability of shows that is not pseudoeffective on a smooth model of the Stein base. Adjunction theory, followed by slope inequalities for the two rulings of a scroll, leaves only degree-three cones over in dimensions . The general resolved fiber is rational, and is either or . If , the threshold estimate contradicts the discrepancy computed by adjunction along . If , monotonicity forces . Relative ampleness on the normalized graph then makes the base locus finite, and the local criterion again proves Cartierness. We carry this out in Section 6.
1.3. Relation to earlier work.
The volume bound underlying the preceding discussion is the following conjecture of Spotti–Sun [SS17, Conjecture 5.5]; see also [LX19, Conjecture 4.5].
Conjecture 1.4 (ODP gap conjecture). Let be a nonsmooth -dimensional klt singularity, with . Then
with equality if and only if is an ordinary double point.
Together with the finite degree formula for normalized volumes, this conjecture would give the required Cartierness directly. Liu–Xu [LX19] proved the three-dimensional case using the classification of canonical and terminal singularities. Liu [Liu22] proved the local complete intersection case in arbitrary dimension and treated cubic fourfolds by studying the limiting linear systems through non-vanishing and degree-six K3 surfaces. Our local criterion follows the approach suggested in [Liu22, Remark 4.8], where higher codimensional alpha invariants and surface sections are used to control the index 1 covers.
Our global threshold estimate comes from the fivefold argument of Kong–Shen–Zhao–Zhao [KSZZ26a]. The contribution here is to relate this estimate systematically to the codimension of the base locus, and to use foliations and adjunction theory for images of smaller dimension. These arguments do not require to be Cartier. They use the established volume bound for local complete intersections, rather than the general ODP gap conjecture.
1.4. An independent proof.
Kong–Shen–Zhao–Zhao [KSZZ26b, Theorem 1.1] give an independent proof of the K-moduli–GIT comparison for cubic hypersurfaces in arbitrary dimension. Both proofs use Liu’s reduction to Cartierness of the limiting hyperplane divisor, the normalized-volume bound for local complete intersections, and tangent-sheaf semistability.
For , they combine slope semistability with vanishing and Koszul resolutions to prove that has minimal degree, then use the classification of such varieties, alpha bounds, and estimates for -invariants to exclude the possible images [KSZZ26b, Propositions 3.1 and 3.4]. Our argument uses kernel foliations and adjunction theory, followed by slope inequalities for the two rulings and the geometry of the general fiber.
For , their proof separates cubic and quadric images and studies the quadrics according to their rank [KSZZ26b, Theorem 4.1]. For quadrics of rank at least four, threshold and multiplicity bounds, together with Abhyankar’s inequality, force the index-one cover to be a local complete intersection. We derive a uniform threshold bound from the codimension of the base locus and obtain the local criterion by cutting to a Gorenstein klt surface.
Acknowledgements. We first thank Junyan Zhao for the discussions about the main ideas of their proof and kindly sharing of their draft [KSZZ26b]. We also thank Zhiyuan Li and Chenyang Xu for their interest in our results and their valuable mathematical advice.
AI disclosure. We are sharing this manuscript with everyone interested in the problem, in the spirit of sharing mathematical knowledge.
We do not claim any traditional academic credit for this paper.
This paper is not intended for publication in a traditional mathematics journal.
LLM(AI) contributed substantive mathematical suggestions, including proof strategies and arguments used in preparing the manuscript. Their principal contribution concerned the lower-dimensional image case as they suggested combining the foliations defined by the rational maps with tangent-sheaf semistability and adjunction theory.
The author reviewed the resulting arguments, removed unnecessary detail, and revised the exposition. In particular, the analysis in Section 5 and Section 6 was simplified. The author takes full responsibility for the mathematical content and its presentation, including any remaining errors or omissions.
This work owes a fundamental intellectual debt to Yuchen Liu and Chenyang Xu. Liu’s study of cubic degenerations through the limiting hyperplane divisor and its linear system is the starting point of our argument. Xu’s work with his collaborators on algebraic K-stability and K-moduli supplies the framework in which it is carried out. The use of AI tools does not alter the attribution of these ideas or the results of other researchers used below.
2. Preliminaries
We work over . Unless otherwise specified, all varieties are assumed to be normal and projective. However, we do not assume normality of the image of a rational map. We always write for a -Gorenstein limit of smooth cubic hypersurfaces.
2.1. Divisors, linear systems, and local thresholds.
For an integral Weil divisor on , we denote by its rank-one reflexive sheaf, and denote by . We set
We use the quotient convention for projective bundles: if is the projective bundle of a vector bundle , then is its tautological quotient line bundle and
Definition 2.1 (Weil linear systems and their base loci). A nonzero subspace determines a linear system of effective Weil divisors. Its geometric base locus is denoted by
If is Cartier, its base ideal is
For a Weil divisor, always means the geometric base locus. It contains the non-Cartier locus of as a member avoiding a point gives a local trivialization of there. Evaluation away from defines the rational map , with the quotient convention above. For the complete system we write .
Let be a normal variety. Let be an effective -divisor on , such that is -Cartier. Then is called a log pair. We say that is a prime divisor over if is a divisor on a normal variety where is a proper birational morphism. We define the log discrepancy of with rrespect to as
We also write be the center of with respect to .
For an ideal , the order is the minimum of the vanishing orders of its local generators along the center of . For a local ring , we write for the height of an ideal and
Definition 2.2 (-Fano varieties). A -Fano variety is a normal projective klt variety with ample -Cartier anticanonical divisor . A log Fano pair consists of a projective klt pair with effective -divisor and ample .
Definition 2.3 (Log canonical thresholds and multiplier ideals). Let be a -Gorenstein klt variety. For a nonzero coherent ideal , set
The log canonical threshold is defined by divisors whose centers contain . For an effective -Cartier divisor , or a linear system of such divisors, we replace by , or
More generally, for a log pair and a log resolution with , one can define the multiplier ideal as following:
We omit when it is zero; products of ideal powers are defined by subtracting the corresponding sum of divisors on a common log resolution.
2.2. K-stability and K-moduli.
Definition 2.4 (Valuative invariants). Let be an -dimensional -Fano variety. Let be an ample -Cartier divisor, and assume be a prime divisor on a smooth projective birational model . Define the -invariant:
Changing variables in the integral gives for . We write and define the K-stability threshold by
where runs over all prime divisors over . For a log Fano pair , one defines by using and .
Theorem 2.5 ([Fuj19, Li17]). A -Fano variety is K-semistable if and only if , equivalently if and only if
for every prime divisor over .
Definition 2.6 (Alpha invariants). For an ample -Cartier divisor on an -dimensional projective klt variety , we define
where ranges over effective -divisors. If is -Fano, we write . For , the higher codimensional alpha invariant is defined by
where is an integer with Cartier and has base scheme of codimension at least . Equivalently, one takes the infimum over codimension- complete intersections of members of ; see [Zhu18, Definition 3.1 and Remark 3.1]. In particular, , and
Theorem 2.7 ([Zhu18, Theorem A]). If is an -dimensional K-semistable -Fano variety, then
In particular, if , then
The comparison with GIT uses three facts from K-moduli theory: existence of polystable replacements, properness of good moduli spaces, and openness of K-semistability. Furthermore, people prove the following K-moduli theorem:
Theorem 2.8. [LWX21] Fix and . The moduli functor which sends any scheme to
each fiber is -dimensional K-semistable ℚ-Fano variety of volume
can be represented by an Artin stack of finite type over . Denoted by . Moreover, it admits a projective good moduli space parameterizing all K-polystable -Fano varieties.
Remark 2.9 (Smoothable families). In the -Gorenstein smoothable setting, proper good moduli spaces were constructed in [LWX19, Theorem 1.3]. For smoothable log pairs with boundary proportional to the anticanonical divisor, existence of K-semistable fillings is established in [ADL19, Theorem 3.19]. Uniqueness of K-polystable limits in families is proved in [BX19].
2.3. Singularities and normalized volumes.
Definition 2.10 (Normalized volumes). Let be an -dimensional klt germ and let be a prime divisor over centered at . Its valuation ideals and volume are defined by:
where denotes length. Define
The latter is called the local volume of germ.
Theorem 2.11. The following normalized-volume estimates hold.
(1) [Liu22, Theorem 2.14]. If is an -dimensional K-semistable -Fano variety, then every closed point satisfies
(2) [Liu22, Theorem 2.13]. If is a finite quasi-étale Galois morphism between klt singularities, then
(3) [Liu22, Theorem 2.12]. If is a non-smooth local complete intersection klt singularity of dimension , then
with equality if and only if it is an ordinary double point.
2.4. Polarized models and foliations.
Definition 2.12 (Polarized birational models). A quasi-polarized pair consists of a normal projective variety and a nef and big Cartier divisor. Two such pairs are said to be polarized birationally equivalent if their polarizations have the same pullback to a common resolution; see [And13, Definition 3.1]. This identifies their section spaces and images of complete linear-series maps.
For a terminal -factorial pair of dimension , a zero reduction is the last pair in a -minimal model program with scaling, where is klt and . The polarization descends through each birational step, so a zero reduction is polarized birationally equivalent to ; see [And13, Proposition 4.2, Definition 4.4, and Remark 4.5(i)]. Definition 2.13 (Slopes). Let be an ample -Cartier divisor on an -dimensional normal projective variety . The slope with respect to of a torsion-free sheaf is defined by
Here is the Weil divisor class of the reflexive determinant ; its intersection with is defined even if that class is not -Cartier. The sheaf is said to be slope semistable if for every coherent subsheaf with . Scaling by a positive rational number does not change semistability.
Definition 2.14 (Foliations). Write for the sheaf of Kähler differentials and for the reflexive tangent sheaf. A subsheaf is saturated if quotient by this subsheaf is torsion-free; its saturation is the smallest saturated subsheaf containing it.
A foliation is a saturated subsheaf which is closed under the Lie bracket. The kernel foliation of a dominant rational map is the saturation of the subsheaf tangent to its general fibers. Its leaves are the maximal connected integral submanifolds on the locus where both and the foliation are regular.
3. Limits of cubic hypersurfaces
3.1. The structure theorem for cubic limits.
We start with Liu’s structure theorem. It supplies the limiting hyperplane class and reduces the possible failure of Cartierness to local index two.
Theorem 3.1 ([Liu22, Theorem 3.1]). Let and let be a K-semistable -Fano family over a smooth pointed curve , whose restriction over is a smooth family of cubic -folds. Put . There is a -Cartier integral Weil divisor class on with the following properties.
(1) is Cohen–Macaulay for every integer .
(2) and .
(3)
(4) Every -Cartier Weil divisor on has Cartier.
Definition 3.2 (The cubic limit pair). Throughout the paper, denotes a K-semistable -Gorenstein limit of smooth cubic -folds with , together with the ample integral -Cartier divisor supplied by Theorem 3.1, unless other hypotheses are stated. In particular, the non-Cartier locus of is contained in the geometric base locus .
3.2. The non-Cartier index 1 covers.
The next lemma explains why it suffices to make the local covers complete intersections. The volume comparison is immediate once we know that the cover is singular; excluding a smooth cover is the step that uses the smoothing.
Lemma 3.3. In the setting of Theorem 3.1, suppose is not Cartier at , and let
Thus any points on the cover cannot be local complete intersection singularities.
Proof. By Theorem 3.1(4), the local Cartier index of at is two. Thus is a quasi-étale double cover with a unique point over . Since and is Cartier, we have
so is Cartier at . Since is quasi-étale and is klt, is also klt and hence Cohen– Macaulay. Together with the Cartierness of , this shows that is Gorenstein at .
We next show that is not smooth at . Suppose, for a contradiction, that is smooth at . After a finite base change if necessary, the construction in the proof of [Liu22, Theorem 3.1] provides a Weil divisor on extending , such that is Cohen–Macaulay and restricts to for every . In particular,
where is a local parameter of at . The right-hand side is invertible, so Nakayama’s lemma shows that the rank-one torsion-free module is cyclic, hence free over the local domain . Thus is Cartier near .
After shrinking around , we can choose a trivialization of compatible with the one defining . The associated cyclic algebra
defines a finite double cover . Since both summands of are flat over , the morphism is flat. The restriction isomorphisms identify its central fiber with the original index-one cover . Over , the cover is étale because is Cartier there.
Then is smooth at and . The deck involution fixes and satisfies . Choose an eigenbasis of the cotangent space containing the class of . Averaging lifts of these eigenvectors, we obtain a regular system of parameters
at such that
Therefore, near , the fixed locus is cut out by . In particular, is smooth at , and is part of a regular system of parameters at . Hence is not contained in the central fiber and meets . This contradicts the fact that acts freely on the étale double cover over .
Now we can apply the local-to-global inequality and the finite degree formula in Theorem 2.11(1)–(2). Since , this give the asserted lower bound. Its ratio to is . By Statement (3) we can excludes a local complete intersection point on the cover.
4. Cartierness from local thresholds
We prove two forms of the local Cartierness criterion. Higher codimensional alpha invariants will give Cartierness at the generic points of the largest base components (Proposition 4.8). A stronger, pointwise threshold bound will exclude every non-Cartier point (Proposition 4.9). Both arguments use Lemma 4.5, which reduces a Gorenstein klt germ to a surface by general Cartier sections.
4.1. Reduction of singularity & Local algebra.
We first recall the local algebra needed for this reduction.
Theorem 4.1 ([LLS08, Corollary 1.4(i)]). Let be a normal log pair. Let be ideals. If generate a reduction of , then for every integer and every real ,
The case without the auxiliary ideal is obtained by taking .
Theorem 4.2 ([NR54]). If is a Noetherian local ring of dimension with infinite residue field and is -primary, then has a reduction generated by elements.
Theorem 4.3 ([Kol13, Section 3.3]). A two-dimensional Gorenstein klt singularity over a characteristic-zero field is geometrically smooth or Du Val. Its embedding dimension is at most three, and its completed local ring is regular or a hypersurface.
Lemma 4.4. Let be a normal -Gorenstein klt variety over a field of characteristic zero, let be a coherent ideal, and let be an irreducible component of of codimension . At the generic point one has
In particular, if every local log canonical threshold of is greater than a real number , then every irreducible component of has codimension greater than .
Proof. Set . This is an -dimensional normal -Gorenstein klt local ring, and is primary for its maximal ideal. Its residue field is an extension of the characteristic-zero ground field and is therefore infinite. The minimal-reduction theorem (Theorem 4.2) gives which generate a reduction of .
Apply the singular Skoda equality of Theorem 4.1 with , , and no auxiliary ideal. It gives
Thus the pair with ideal coefficient is not klt. Since the ambient germ is klt, the klt threshold and the log canonical threshold agree as a supremum, so . The final assertion follows by applying this inequality at the generic point of every component.
Lemma 4.5. Let be a Gorenstein klt local germ of dimension over a characteristic-zero field, and let be a proper ideal. Assume
Then is a local complete intersection at . More precisely, its completed local ring is regular or a hypersurface.
Proof. If , the assertion is Theorem 4.3. Suppose and put . Choose a rational number such that
By Lemma 4.4, . Since is Cohen–Macaulay, sufficiently general linear combinations of generators of form a regular sequence. Set and .
We claim that each is Gorenstein klt and that is klt near . This holds for by the choice of . For the induction step, the height inequality
ensures that has no divisorial component. Let be a general Cartier member. On a log resolution of , it has the same vanishing orders as along the exceptional divisors, and its free part is smooth by Bertini. Replacing one factor of by therefore preserves the strict discrepancy inequalities and gives a plt pair
near . Here the notation records an ideal with its indicated exponent. Cartier adjunction then gives the asserted klt pair on ; see [Kol97, Theorems 4.8 and 7.5(1)]. Gorensteinness is preserved by each Cartier cut.
Thus is a Gorenstein klt surface germ. The strict inequality in the hypothesis is used to retain klt singularities after all cuts. By Theorem 4.3, . Quotienting a local ring by elements lowers its embedding dimension by at most , so
Since is Cohen–Macaulay, a minimal Cohen presentation of its completion has kernel generated by at most one element. Hence the completion is regular or a hypersurface, and is a local complete intersection at .
4.2. Local thresholds and Cartierness.
The preceding lemma applies in the local dimension, which may be smaller than at a generic point of the base locus. This is why the higher codimensional alpha bound is sufficient for the next two statements.
Let be an integral -Cartier Weil divisor on a normal projective klt variety , and put . If has local Cartier index at , denote by
the index cover associated to , of degree . All such covers are understood as covers of germs. Put , which is Cartier.
Definition 4.6. The pullbacks of the sections in the fixed space define the coherent ideal sheaf
We call the local degree-one base ideal.
After trivializing near , it is generated by the functions representing the pullbacks of all global sections of . Where is Cartier, we take and the identity cover.
Let be a normalized divisorial valuation over whose center contains . Write , where is a prime divisor over and is the ramification index. Sincethe cover is cyclic of degree , we have . Quasi-étaleness and crepancy give
where
Lemma 4.7. Let be an -dimensional K-semistable -Fano variety, and let be an integral -Cartier Weil divisor such that
Proof. Choose a positive integer divisible by both and , and set . The image
is a linear subsystem of . Its set-theoretic base locus is as a degree-one section nonvanishing at a point gives a nonvanishing -th power, while at a degree-one base point every product vanishes. Set , a coherent ideal sheaf on . The base scheme of has codimension at least . Applying Zhu’s theorem (Theorem 2.7) on higher codimensional alpha invariants and using the scaling rule for log canonical thresholds, we obtain
Pullback is compatible with multiplication under the identification . Thus, writing for the ideal sheaf on the chosen cover, we have
Since the quasi-étale crepant cover preserves thresholds,
Since the local threshold is at least the global threshold, and , it follows that
Finally,
because .
Proposition 4.8. Let be a K-semistable -Gorenstein limit of smooth cubic -folds, , with as in Theorem 3.1. If is nonempty, set . Then every irreducible component of of codimension is generically contained in the Cartier locus of .
In particular, if is finite, then is Cartier.
Proof. Assume first that is nonempty, and let be a codimension- component with generic point . If , the Cartierness at can be deduced from the normality of . In the following let’s assume that and is not Cartier at .
Take the index cover
Thereore, applying Lemma 4.5, in dimension , we deduce that the cover is local complete intersection at .
Trivializing near extends the index cover to a finite cover . By openness of the local complete intersection locus and finiteness of , we may shrink so that is a local complete intersection. The non-Cartier locus of is closed and contains , hence . Thus any closed point of contradicts Lemma 3.3. This proves the first assertion.
If is finite, the first assertion shows that is Cartier at every point of .
Proposition 4.9. Let be as in Definition 3.2, and let be a closed non-Cartier point of . On its index cover
Proof. The cover is Gorenstein klt, and is proper because a non-Cartier point belongs to . If its threshold were greater than , Lemma 4.5 would make the cover a local complete intersection, contrary to Lemma 3.3.
5. Linear systems and mixed intersections
The normalized graph of a linear system separates its moving and fixed parts. We use their mixed intersections to estimate the codimension of the base locus and, under K-semistability, the log canonical threshold of the ideal of the lifted sections on index 1 covers. We then apply these estimates to linear systems with full-dimensional image and prove the Cartierness of the hyperplane class on K-semistable cubic limits.
Throughout this section, let be a normal projective variety of dimension , and let be an ample integral -Cartier Weil divisor with .
5.1. The normalized graph.
Set
and write . As above, denotes the geometric base locus of . Choose a positive integer such that is Cartier. All base loci are geometric base loci in the sense of Definition 2.1. Since we use the complete linear system, is integral and nondegenerate; we make no assumption on its normality.
Let
Take to be the normalization of the blowup of , thus is the normalized graph, independent of , with morphisms and fitting into the diagram
Let . Put and . Both and are nef, and is Cartier, globally generated, and -ample. Moreover,
The support satisfies set-theoretically, and is the fixed -divisor of .
5.2. Mixed intersections and threshold estimates.
Define the mixed intersections on the normalized graph by
They are unchanged by pullback to any higher birational model. On such a model, we continue to write for their pullbacks; when comparing two models, we write the pullbacks explicitly. For a prime divisor over , let be the minimal vanishing order along of a member of . On a model carrying , this is the coefficient of in the pull-back of the fixed divisor .
We first show how the mixed intersections reflect the dimension of the image and the codimension of the base locus.
Lemma 5.1. The mixed intersections satisfy
If and , then
Proof. Since is effective and are nef,
Also , and for because is pulled back from .
Suppose has codimension . For , the effective cycle has dimension , whereas its image under lies in . Hence . The projection formula gives
proving the equalities. For there is only .
To prove the strict inequality, choose an irreducible component of of codimension , and let be its generic point. Since , some prime component of dominates . Its generic fiber has dimension . The projection formula gives
by the ampleness of and the -ampleness of . All components of have nonnegative intersection with the nef classes , and the coefficient of in is positive. Hence
This is the positivity argument of [HP24, proof of Theorem 3.2, Step 2].
Thus the codimension of a nonempty base locus is the index of the first strict drop in the mixed-intersection sequence. In particular, equality of the first mixed intersections characterizes finiteness of the base locus.
Corollary 5.2. The geometric base locus is finite if and only if
Proof. If , then , so and all the mixed intersections equal . Otherwise, Lemma 5.1 shows that the displayed equalities hold if and only if , which is equivalent to finiteness.
The segment joining and gives a lower bound for the volume integral defining in terms of the mixed intersections. This is the key estimate for relating the codimension of the base locus to the log canonical threshold of the lifted base ideal on a index cover.
Lemma 5.3. For every prime divisor over ,
Assume in addition that is a K-semistable -Fano variety and for some . Set
Then
Proof. Choose a smooth model carrying , and use for the pulled-back divisors. Then . The volume bound is immediate if . Otherwise, for ,
The divisor on the right is nef. Monotonicity of volume and integration over give
Here
On an index 1 cover, the same estimate bounds the log canonical threshold of the lifted base ideal. Comparing it with the local upper bound at the generic point of a base component relates to the codimension of the base locus.
Lemma 5.4. Assume that is a K-semistable -Fano variety and for some , and let be as in Lemma 5.3. Fix a non-Cartier point of , of local index , and let
The same bound holds at a Cartier point of , using and the identity cover. If and , then .
Proof. As in the proof of Lemma 4.7, we have
where is the base ideal of Section 5.1. By Lemma 5.3, we obtain . The valuative formula for the log canonical threshold gives the asserted local bound, including the identity-cover case.
Now let be the generic point of a codimension- component of . Choose a index cover
the ideal is primary for the maximal ideal of the -dimensional klt local ring . Apply the local bound just proved at . Thus Lemma 4.4 gives
5.3. The full-dimensional image.
For a full-dimensional image, its degree gives a lower bound for the last mixed intersection. Combining this with Lemmas 5.1 and 5.4 first bounds the codimension of the base locus, and then improves the threshold estimate.
Proposition 5.5. Let be an -dimensional K-semistable -Fano variety, where , and let be an ample integral -Cartier Weil divisor such that
Assume . Then
If , it has codimension at least .
In particular, if is a cubic limit pair as in Definition 3.2, then is Cartier.
Proof. If , then and for all , so . We may therefore assume for the numerical assertions. Put . We first bound , then substitute that bound back into the estimate for .
The nondegenerate image is a hypersurface of degree at least two. If is the degree of , then
By Lemma 5.1, every is at least two, while the first terms equal three. Therefore by Lemma 5.4,
which yields
Thus . The first mixed intersections now equal three, and the last two are at least two. Substituting gives
Finally, suppose is a cubic limit pair. The threshold bound on index 1 covers from Lemma 5.4 contradicts Proposition 4.9 at any closed non-Cartier point. Hence is Cartier.
6. The lower-dimensional image
In this section, we determine the image of the rational map when . After passing to the Stein base, tangent-sheaf semistability gives an adjunction obstruction. The section count and the alpha bound then reduce the stein base to a scroll. The numerical contrain by its two rulings exclude the cases for and leave only degree-three Segre cones in dimensions five, six, and seven, and their general resolved fibers are rational curves. These arguments do not require or Cartierness of . We impose those assumptions in Section 6.3, where the estimates of Section 5.2 force the base locus to be finite.
Throughout this section, unless otherwise stated, let be an -dimensional K-semistable -Fano variety with , and let be an ample integral -Cartier Weil divisor such that
We retain the notation of Section 5.1; in particular, and . By Theorem 2.7,
Every cubic limit pair satisfies these assumptions by Theorem 3.1.
6.1. The Stein factorization and adjunction.
Let and be the normalized graph of Section 5.1. Factor as , where has connected fibers and is finite. The Stein base is normal. Put , an ample globally generated Cartier divisor, so that on . Choose a smooth resolution , and resolve the component of dominating to obtain a smooth . We have a commutative diagram
The morphism and have connected fibers, since their Stein factors over the normal target is finite birational. Set
The divisor is nef and big. Using the pullback convention of Section 5.1, on we have
On the normalized graph, write for the movable Weil divisor class on . The projection formula gives
Completeness of gives
The first identification is part of Section 5.1; the others follow from connected fibers and normality. Thus is the map defined by the complete system . We will use this to prove that has degree one.
These constructions use only the general hypotheses at the beginning of Section 5. The K-semistable Fano assumptions enter through the following semistability theorem. Since , slope semistability with respect to is equivalent to slope semistability with respect to .
Theorem 6.1 ([DGP20, Theorem 2.6(i) and Remark 2.4]). Let be a complex K-semistable -Fano variety. Then its reflexive tangent sheaf is slope semistable with respect to .
We will show that is not pseudoeffective. The following adjunction theorem then restricts the polarized birational type of the Stein base.
Theorem 6.2 ([And13, Theorem 5.1(3) and Proposition 3.5(A)]). Let be a quasi-polarized variety of dimension with terminal -factorial singularities, where is a nef and big Cartier divisor. Then is not pseudoeffective if and only if any zero reduction of is one of , a quadric with its hyperplane polarization, a generalized cone over , or a -bundle over a smooth curve with polarization restricting to on the fibers. Here zero reductions and polarized birational equivalence are as in Definition 2.12.
6.2. The Stein base and its fibers.
We first establish the adjunction obstruction. This step only uses K-semistability and the relation ; the dimension bound and section count will enter the classification.
Lemma 6.3. Let be an -dimensional K-semistable -Fano variety with , and let be an ample integral -Cartier Weil divisor with . Assume and . For the resolved Stein base of Section 6.1, the divisor is not pseudoeffective.
Proof. Use and from Section 6.1. Following [HP24, Lemma 2.6 and Section 6], saturate the image of in . Its determinant is , where as saturation adds the effective divisor contributed by the codimension-one torsion in the quotient. The kernel foliation has rank and first Chern class . Push it to and saturate in . Since and saturation can only increase the determinant, the resulting foliation satisfies
If is pseudoeffective for a nonnegative real number , its pullback to has nonnegative intersection with . The projection formula, the preceding inequality, and give
By Theorem 6.1, the tangent sheaf is semistable with respect to , and hence with respect to . Hence
The strict inequality is exactly
Under the standing assumptions of this section, we can now classify the Stein base.
Proposition 6.4. Assume . Let be the finite map in the Stein factorization of a resolution of . Then
and the projective image of is normal and isomorphic to the cone over the Segre embedding of , with vertex , where a vertex of dimension means no vertex.
The finite map in the Stein factorization has degree one and is an isomorphism. Equivalently, the polarized Stein base is the ample model of
Proof. Since , no member contains a prime divisor on with coefficient as least two. Otherwise would give
Lemma 6.5. .
Proof. If , then is a surjective morphism to a smooth projective curve. Rationality of klt singularities identifies with , and the latter vanishes by Kawamata–Viehweg vanishing. Hodge symmetry therefore gives .
The pullback map
is injective by the generic smoothnss. Thus , so has genus zero and as has connected fibers. Then
For , let be as in Lemma 6.3, then Theorem 6.2 applies. The projective space and quadric cases have respectively and independent sections, both smaller than , and hence are excluded as polarized birational equivalence preserves every section space and the complete linear-series maps.
The generalized Veronese-cone case is excluded by double hyperplanes. A square of a linear form on gives a hyperplane section equal to twice the cone over its line. Vary the line and we get a moving family of hyperplane sections whose general member meets the open set where the rational map from to the polarized model is a morphism. So its inverse image of the support of the hyperplane section has a codimension-one component on and the pulled-back hyperplane has coefficient at least two along that component. This again contradicts the alpha bound.
It remains to consider the projective-bundle alternative. Its base curve is by the preceding vanishing argument. Up to tensoring a line bundle from the base, we may write with . The polarization is nef, so . If some , choose a section supported in that summand with a double zero at a general point of . Its hyperplane divisor contains twice the fiber over that point. The same open-set pullback argument contradicts . Therefore all belong to .
Let . The section count gives
The complete tautological map of this scroll is birational onto the cone over with the stated vertex. The Segre embedding is projectively normal, so its homogeneous coordinate ring is integrally closed. The homogeneous coordinate ring of is the polynomial extension , which is also integrally closed. Hence is normal.
It remains to identify the Stein base with this image. Polarized birational equivalence identifies all section spaces of and , and therefore identifies their complete linear-series maps. The latter map is birational on , so the complete map of also has degree one. Thus is finite birational. Normality of the Segre cone now implies that is an isomorphism.
The classification alone still permits scrolls of larger degree. Their two rulings give competing lower bounds on divisor classes whose sum is bounded by . This is the second use of tangentsheaf semistability.
Write for the bundle projection and for the morphism defined by .
Lemma 6.6. Assume . Use the scroll and the integer of Proposition 6.4. There are effective movable Weil divisor classes and on such that is effective and
In particular,
or equivalently .
Proof. On put and . The first class gives the map to , while the sections of coming from the positive summands give the dominant rational map to . Resolve both rational maps on a common model dominating and . Take their movable hyperplane divisors and push them to , calling the resulting classes and . The multiplication of a section of and a section of is a section of . After resolving and removing fixed parts, this gives . This inequality allows all exceptional fixed parts; it does not assume that either ruling divisor is Cartier on .
Apply the cotangent-saturation calculation of Lemma 6.3 to the rational maps to and . Their kernel foliations and have ranks and and satisfy
Writing and , tangent semistability gives
Rearranging gives the claimed lower bounds. Adding them and using proves the final inequality.
Proposition 6.7. If , the complete linear system is generically finite onto its image. If and is not generically finite, its image has dimension and is the degree-three cone over the Segre embedding of , with vertex . The corresponding scroll model is
with its tautological polarization.
Proof. Suppose . Proposition 6.4 gives and , or equivalently . If , the inequality in Lemma 6.6 gives the contradiction.
For , the condition forces .
For or , the two-ruling forces .
Thus only and remain. Then , and Proposition 6.4 gives the stated image and scroll model.
The remaining images have dimension one less than . We next show that their general resolved fibers are rational curves. The ruling of the Segre cone makes the induced rank-one foliation positive along a general complete-intersection curve, so we can apply the following theorem. Theorem 6.8 ([BM16, Main theorem], See also [KSCT07, Theorem 1]). Let be a normal complex projective variety, let be a complete curve, and let be a possibly singular foliation which is regular along . If is an ample vector bundle, then the leaf through every point of is algebraic, and the closure of the leaf through a general point of is rationally connected.
Lemma 6.9. Assume , then a smooth connected general fiber of a resolution of is isomorphic to .
Proof. By Proposition 6.4, is an isomorphism. Identify with , so . Let be its scroll model, with tautological class , and let be its ruling class. The projective-bundle formula gives
Apply the construction of Section 6.1 with and , so and . Then , , and . Saturate the image of in . Its determinant is for an effective divisor . The induced rank-one kernel foliation, pushed to and saturated in , therefore satisfies
Here is the movable divisor of the dominant rational map induced by the ruling. In particular, is effective and nonzero. Since and is ample, we obtain .
Choose a sufficiently general complete-intersection curve using a large very ample Cartier multiple of . Normality makes have codimension at least two. The singular locus of a saturated foliation on the smooth locus also has codimension at least two. Thus is smooth and avoids both singular loci. The restriction is a line bundle of positive degree, so it is ample. By Theorem 6.8, the closure of the leaf through a general point of is rationally connected.
By generic smoothness, choose a nonempty open subset such that is smooth. This restriction of is a proper smooth family of connected curves, whose genus is constant because is irreducible. Let be a nonempty open subset over which is an isomorphism and such that . On , the foliation is tangent to the fibers of the morphism .
For a sufficiently general choice of above, take a general point , and put . The smooth connected fiber maps birationally under onto the closure of the leaf through . The preceding application of Theorem 6.8 shows that is rationally connected, so its normalization has genus zero. Constancy of the genus over now implies that every closed fiber of is isomorphic to . Since is birational, the general fibers of and coincide. Further smooth birational resolutions preserve this conclusion, since their smooth proper generic curve fibers are birational and hence isomorphic.
6.3. The residual Segre cases.
Throughout this subsection, we assume in addition that
is Cartier
By Proposition 6.7, one has and , and the Stein base is the normal degree-three cone over with vertex . Identify with via , so . Keep the smooth model of Section 6.1. The morphism has connected fibers, and . Taking in Section 5.1 gives Cartier, and the coefficient in Lemma 5.3 becomes
Let be a smooth connected general fiber of . By Lemma 6.9, one has . Let be the non-Cartier locus of .
The volume and Cartierness of leave two possible fiber degrees. The codimension of the base locus distinguishes them.
Lemma 6.10. One has
Moreover, is nonempty and, writing , one has
Proof. Since is Cartier, we have . The birational morphism is an isomorphism on a dense open subset met by the general fiber of . Hence is a nonzero effective curve, and ampleness of gives
Since , one also has , so is nonempty. Denote by .
Recall that and . Since is a smooth connected general fiber of , the projection formula yields
If , by Lemma 5.1 we have
Thus . Since we already know that , it follows that . If , the same lemma gives , so . This completes the proof.
It remains to exclude the case , or equivalently, to show that is finite. As in the full-dimensional case, we first use the threshold estimate to obtain a lower bound for the codimension of , and then use this codimension bound to sharpen the threshold estimate.
Lemma 6.11. Suppose . Then has codimension at least , and
Proof. Since has degree three and dimension , projection formula gives
Set ; by Lemma 6.10, one has . By Lemma 5.1, one has for and . We also have by Lemma 5.4. Therefore
whence
The last inequality uses . Thus , and the first mixed intersections equal three. The two remaining terms through are at least , so
The half-integrality of is decisive in the next argument: a general fiber with meets exactly one component of , with . We show that is also the only -exceptional divisor meeting . Adjunction along then gives a value for its log discrepancy that contradicts the preceding threshold estimate.
Lemma 6.12. The possibility does not occur.
Proof. Suppose . Take sufficiently general over the smooth locus of , so that is smooth near . Recall that . Write
where the are distinct prime divisors and , since is Cartier. A general fiber is not contained in any , so each is a nonnegative integer. Since , one has
Consequently there is exactly one component meeting , and
By Lemma 6.11, the base locus has codimension at least . Thus has no fixed divisorial component, and every component of is -exceptional. If a -exceptional prime divisor is not in , its center is not contained in the base locus. Near the generic point of that center the map is a morphism, so
Write the discrepancy formula as
Since is smooth near the general fiber , its normal bundle is trivial and
. Only contributes to the sum, and ; hence
Thus . On the other hand, Lemmas 5.3 and 6.11 give
a contradiction.
With the half-degree case excluded, Lemma 6.10 now gives finiteness of the base locus.
Corollary 6.13. The geometric base locus is finite. In particular, if is a K-semistable limit of smooth cubic hypersurfaces, then the image of has dimension .
Proof. Lemmas 6.10 and 6.12 give . Thus is finite. For a cubic limit, the image of has dimension by Proposition 6.7 for . For , if the image has dimension , then by the finiteness of the base locus and Proposition 4.8, we have is Cartier and is very ample by [Fuj90, Corollary 1.7]. This contradicts Proposition 6.7, so the image has dimension .
References
[ABHLX20] Jarod Alper, Harold Blum, Daniel Halpern-Leistner, and Chenyang Xu, Reductivity of the automorphism group of K-polystable Fano varieties, Invent. Math. 222 (2020), no. 3, 995–1032. MR 4169054
[ADL19] Kenneth Ascher, Kristin DeVleming, and Yuchen Liu, Wall crossing for K-moduli spaces of plane curves, 2019, arXiv:1909.04576v2.
[And13] Marco Andreatta, Minimal model program with scaling and adjunction theory, International Journal of Mathematics 24 (2013), no. 2, 1350007, 13 pp.; doi:10.1142/S0129167X13500079.
[BLX22] Harold Blum, Yuchen Liu, and Chenyang Xu, Openness of K-semistability for Fano varieties, Duke Math. J. 171 (2022), no. 13, 2753–2797. MR 4505846
[BM16] Fedor Bogomolov and Michael McQuillan, Rational Curves on Foliated Varieties, Foliation Theory in Algebraic Geometry (Cham) (Paolo Cascini, James McKernan, and Jorge Vitório Pereira, eds.), Springer International Publishing, 2016, pp. 21–51.
[BX19] Harold Blum and Chenyang Xu, Uniqueness of K-polystable degenerations of Fano varieties, Annals of Mathematics. Second Series 190 (2019), 609–656, arXiv:1812.03538.
[DGP20] Stéphane Druel, Henri Guenancia, and Mihai Păun, A decomposition theorem for Q-Fano Kähler– Einstein varieties, 2020, arXiv:2008.05352v1.
[Don02] S. K. Donaldson, Scalar curvature and stability of toric varieties, J. Differential Geom. 62 (2002), no. 2, 289–349. MR 1988506
[Fuj90] Takao Fujita, On singular del Pezzo varieties, Algebraic Geometry (L’Aquila, 1988), Lecture Notes in Mathematics, no. 1417, Springer, Berlin, 1990, pp. 117–128.
[Fuj19] Kento Fujita, A valuative criterion for uniform K-stability of Q-Fano varieties, J. Reine Angew. Math. 751 (2019), 309–338. MR 3956698
[HP24] Andreas Höring and Thomas Peternell, Klt degenerations of projective spaces, 2024, arXiv:2403.05250v2.
[Jia20] Chen Jiang, Boundedness of Q-Fano varieties with degrees and alpha-invariants bounded from below, Ann. Sci. Éc. Norm. Supér. (4) 53 (2020), no. 5, 1235–1248. MR 4174851
[Kol97] János Kollár, Singularities of pairs, Algebraic Geometry (Santa Cruz, 1995), Proceedings of Symposia in Pure Mathematics, vol. 62, Part I, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 1997, arXiv:alg-geom/9601026v2, pp. 221–287.
[Kol13] —, Singularities of the minimal model program, Cambridge Tracts in Mathematics, no. 200, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2013.
[KSCT07] Stefan Kebekus, Luis Solá Conde, and Matei Toma, Rationally connected foliations after Bogomolov and McQuillan, Journal of Algebraic Geometry 16 (2007), 65–81, arXiv:math/0505222v3.
[KSZZ26a] Bochao Kong, Yu Shen, Junyan Zhao, and Minghao Zhao, K-moduli of cubic fivefolds, 2026, Preprint, September 6, 2026.
[KSZZ26b] —, K-moduli of cubic hypersurfaces, 2026, Preprint, September 30, 2026; author’s webpage, item 18.
[Li17] Chi Li, K-semistability is equivariant volume minimization, Duke Mathematical Journal 166 (2017), 3147–3218, arXiv:1512.07205.
[Li18] —, Minimizing normalized volumes of valuations, Math. Z. 289 (2018), no. 1-2, 491–513. MR 3803800
[Liu22] Yuchen Liu, K-stability of cubic fourfolds, Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik 786 (2022), 55–77, doi:10.1515/crelle-2022-0002.
[LLS08] Robert Lazarsfeld, Kyungyong Lee, and Karen E. Smith, Syzygies of multiplier ideals on singular varieties, Michigan Mathematical Journal 57 (2008), 511–521, arXiv:0804.4188v2.
[LWX19] Chi Li, Xiaowei Wang, and Chenyang Xu, On the proper moduli spaces of smoothable Kähler– Einstein Fano varieties, Duke Mathematical Journal 168 (2019), 1387–1459, arXiv:1411.0761v4.
[LWX21] —, Algebraicity of the metric tangent cones and equivariant K-stability, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 34 (2021), no. 4, 1175–1214. MR 4301561
[LX19] Yuchen Liu and Chenyang Xu, K-stability of cubic threefolds, Duke Mathematical Journal 168 (2019), no. 11, 2029–2073, doi:10.1215/00127094-2019-0006.
[LXZ22] Yuchen Liu, Chenyang Xu, and Ziquan Zhuang, Finite generation for valuations computing stability thresholds and applications to K-stability, Ann. of Math. (2) 196 (2022), no. 2, 507–566. MR 4445441
[NR54] D. G. Northcott and D. Rees, Reductions of ideals in local rings, Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 50 (1954), 145–158.
[OSS16] Yuji Odaka, Cristiano Spotti, and Song Sun, Compact moduli spaces of del Pezzo surfaces and Kähler-Einstein metrics, J. Differential Geom. 102 (2016), no. 1, 127–172. MR 3447088
[PT06] Sean Timothy Paul and Gang Tian, CM stability and the generalized Futaki invariant I, 2006, arXiv:math/0605278.
[SS17] Cristiano Spotti and Song Sun, Explicit Gromov-Hausdorff compactifications of moduli spaces of Kähler-Einstein Fano manifolds, Pure Appl. Math. Q. 13 (2017), no. 3, 477–515. MR 3882206
[Tia97] Gang Tian, Kähler-Einstein metrics with positive scalar curvature, Invent. Math. 130 (1997), no. 1, 1–37. MR 1471884
[XZ20] Chenyang Xu and Ziquan Zhuang, On positivity of the CM line bundle on K-moduli spaces, Ann. of Math. (2) 192 (2020), no. 3, 1005–1068. MR 4172625
[Zhu18] Ziwen Zhu, Higher codimensional alpha invariants and characterization of projective spaces, 2018, arXiv:1805.07330v2.